Senator Mark Kelly’s (D., Ariz.) Make AI Work for Americans Act aims to make companies that profit from artificial intelligence pay their “fair share” and use those proceeds to “invest in American workers.” The bill would create an AI Horizon Fund — financed by three new taxes and overseen by a 15-member AI Advisory Council — to expand job training, national service, small business support, and unemployment benefits.
The premise and assumptions behind the bill are clear: AI has been, and will be, displacing workers on a large enough scale that it necessitates a new federal trust fund. But this is counter to most of the evidence we have about AI and the economy. Economists have yet to find clear signs of broad labor market disruption, even among heavily AI-exposed industries or entry-level openings. Even on its own terms, the bill’s design has massive problems regarding how it raises taxes, how it spends that money, and who makes the spending decisions.
To finance the Horizon Fund, three new taxes are to be levied: A 5 percent tax on digital advertising, a 50 percent tax on AI companies’ profits (in excess of 40 percent of gross receipts), and an excise tax on the output of AI models. But economics tells us that he who writes the check is not necessarily he who actually pays the tax. After countries like France, Italy, Turkey, and the United Kingdom imposed digital services taxes, Apple, Amazon, and Google passed those costs directly to advertisers, third-party sellers, and app developers. A usage tax could be even worse for the consumer. While one reason the bill’s supporters want the tax would be to slow down AI job replacement, a blanket usage tax would be one-size-fits-all and not distinguish between use cases that replace vs. complement human labor.
Continue reading at National Review.
Justin Callais, PhD, is Chief Economist at the Archbridge Institute. He leads the institute's "Social Mobility in the 50 States" project and conducts original research on economic development, upward mobility, and economic freedom. Dr. Callais received his Ph.D. in economics from Texas Tech University and his B.B.A. in economics from Loyola University New Orleans. He serves as an economic consultant at Callais Capital Management, and he is co-editor of Profectus Magazine, an online publication dedicated to human progress and flourishing. In addition, he publishes a regular newsletter on Substack titled "Debunking Degrowth."
Economics of Flourishing
Senator Mark Kelly’s (D., Ariz.) Make AI Work for Americans Act aims to make companies that profit from artificial intelligence pay their “fair share” and use those proceeds to “invest in American workers.” The bill would create an AI Horizon Fund — financed by three new taxes and overseen by a 15-member AI Advisory Council — to expand job training, national service, small business support, and unemployment benefits.
The premise and assumptions behind the bill are clear: AI has been, and will be, displacing workers on a large enough scale that it necessitates a new federal trust fund. But this is counter to most of the evidence we have about AI and the economy. Economists have yet to find clear signs of broad labor market disruption, even among heavily AI-exposed industries or entry-level openings. Even on its own terms, the bill’s design has massive problems regarding how it raises taxes, how it spends that money, and who makes the spending decisions.
To finance the Horizon Fund, three new taxes are to be levied: A 5 percent tax on digital advertising, a 50 percent tax on AI companies’ profits (in excess of 40 percent of gross receipts), and an excise tax on the output of AI models. But economics tells us that he who writes the check is not necessarily he who actually pays the tax. After countries like France, Italy, Turkey, and the United Kingdom imposed digital services taxes, Apple, Amazon, and Google passed those costs directly to advertisers, third-party sellers, and app developers. A usage tax could be even worse for the consumer. While one reason the bill’s supporters want the tax would be to slow down AI job replacement, a blanket usage tax would be one-size-fits-all and not distinguish between use cases that replace vs. complement human labor.
Continue reading at National Review.
Nicholas Thielman
Justin T. Callais
Justin Callais, PhD, is Chief Economist at the Archbridge Institute. He leads the institute's "Social Mobility in the 50 States" project and conducts original research on economic development, upward mobility, and economic freedom. Dr. Callais received his Ph.D. in economics from Texas Tech University and his B.B.A. in economics from Loyola University New Orleans. He serves as an economic consultant at Callais Capital Management, and he is co-editor of Profectus Magazine, an online publication dedicated to human progress and flourishing. In addition, he publishes a regular newsletter on Substack titled "Debunking Degrowth."
Share:
Related Posts
Proposition 40 Failed, But California Already Suffered From It
Rigid Labor Rules and Red Tape Are Holding Back Europe’s Upward Mobility
New York Fights Over a Rent Freeze. Minneapolis Has Results
Related Posts
None found